Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
mikemikeb
Participantif you don’t have a handheld meter, change the metering system on your camera to ‘spot’
I also have a Rebel XT and there is no spot metering on the camera. The closest thing to that is “partial metered”, which works fine enough.
To access this:
1. In standby mode, press the left key on the circle-shaped button array on the back of the camera
2. Press the down key until the middle of the three options is highlighted
3. Press SET (the button in the middle of the circled array)
4. Press the shutter halfway to return to standby modeNormal evaluative metering is the top of the three options in the metering menu.
mikemikeb
ParticipantExcept she also mentioned she’s going to give Photomatix a try, as well as GIMP which she already has experience with.
Right, and she’s only wanting to try Photomatix because CS2 doesn’t work right. If she can get it to, it would be a waste of $100 to get the standalone Photomatix program (if she doesn’t want the watermarks).
It also doesn’t change the fact that I was discussing a specific process (a discussion aimed at her since she did originally ask me rather specifically), and it also doesn’t change the fact that she’s working on multiple platforms, so the points I brought up are specifically germane to her system(s) and options she may want to consider.
You are correct. If she can’t get CS2 to work, I’m glad that you’re opening her eyes to other options. I wasn’t really looking in that field, but was thinking more proactively in getting CS2 to work vs. using other systems. Different strategies to get to the same sort of result. Sorry for any confusion.
But by all means, please feel free to keep nitpicking the things I say rather than concede that I have anything of value to add to a conversation that was aimed at me in the first place 🙄
Oh I know that you do bring some good stuff to the table. I’ve never doubted that, and I’m sorry if I’ve given off the impression otherwise.
I think Photomatix has a CS/PS plugin, which might help streamline things. Hopefully someone more in the CS/PS know can clarify and/or give you a way to fool Adobe on single RAW HDR!
You are correct that there is a plugin available. However, I think that only does tone mapping, which is a very difficult tool to properly master, and it probably won’t fix the Photoshop issue.
If anyone does have luck with split RAW images and photoshop, though, I would feel greatly vindicated in knowing how the heck it is done!!!
I don’t know for sure, but I would guess that you should open up your unedited RAW file in CS2/Camera RAW, and save whatever comes up as a 16-bit RGBA PNG file. From there, close CS2 (this stuff is done in case the program remembers what you did otherwise!), and re-open it. Once re-open, open up the PNG you just saved, and work from there. You can try what you’ve done before, or what Elsinore suggested (decreasing exposure and saving as second PNG, then increasing the exposure, and saving that as a PNG…), and so on and so on. I hope that works.
In a way, I hope CS3 (or better yet, the next version of Camera RAW) has an HDR tool where it can take one RAW file and it finds all the hidden shadow and highlight detail and correctly creates an HDR image out of it (and no tone mapping). That would be so cool.
mikemikeb
ParticipantBecause chakalakasp‘s tutorial (see above link) talks about how one’s supposed to downsample all the way to 8 bit in CS2 and save a JPEG from there (and to save 16-bit and up files before downsampling to 8-bit, as well). I trust what he says there.
That’s great if you’re using a single program and it makes total sense in that context. It won’t work as well for the method I’m discussing with anneb, the method I use which requires more than one program.
anneb wants to use CS2 alone:
I’ll tell you, it was really cool playing with the curves on the HDR merge in CS2, I felt like I had some semblance of fine tuning control, even on my first real attempt at it. And, in the interests of keeping my life simple, I’d rather get things to work in Photoshop.
I know that you have to do things differently as you use Linux. Sorry for any confusion.
So are you using GIMP for general image editing?
Yeah. I currently only work with JPEG, though I do have RAW versions of some photos (like the HDR theme sources).
mikemikeb
ParticipantAs for going from 12bit RAW to 8bit png and dynamic range loss, isn’t that what I said and you quoted? GIMP only works in 8bit, so there’s dynamic range loss anyway.
I wasn’t quite sure if lowering bits always means lowering DR. I’m not as much of a techie as you are.
In addition, I talked about how you don’t need to open up GIMP until you have the final full-sized JPEG of the intended image, as long as you have CS2, or Photomatix, or a combination of other image tools that do work in 16-bit.
Given that jpg is lossy while png/tiff are not, why would you want to output a jpg from CS2 to work in GIMP or qpfstmo? If you’re outputting to an 8bit file anyway, lossless would certainly be preferable to lossy….
Because chakalakasp‘s tutorial (see above link of mine) talks about how one’s supposed to downsample all the way to 8 bit in CS2 and save a JPEG from there (and to save 16-bit and up files before downsampling to 8-bit as well). I trust what he says there.
But GIMP’s image scaling and jpg compression are absolutely underappreciated. I learned just how good GIMP is with scaling/compression when I tried out Bibble, which output greater compression artifacts at larger file sizes for the same compression level as GIMP. That was probably one of the biggest drawbacks of Bibble for me.
And then there’s Photoshop. With the JPEG compression tool alone, there’s not as much compression fine-tuning (in Photoshop, it’s “10” vs. “11” quality, versus something like 85 and 86% quality in GIMP), or real-time image size preview, or as many ways to customize the final image (is EXIF data desired, is 1×1, 1×1, 1×1 or 2×2, 1×1, 1×1 color subsampling desired, etc.). I don’t even know for sure how good it does at compression of smaller images (proportionally vs. GIMP) because the JPEG editor is so feature-poor I don’t bother using it anymore (except for when I was just re-checking it out to get my stats checked). I won’t even get to the image scaling tool.
(Edited to add full disclosure: I have Elements 3 installed on my computer. If you have CS2, and it seems like I’m making baseless facts, I’m sorry. If I’m mostly, or even 100% right about your version, even though I’ve never operated it, then Adobe, um, let’s just say they have some work to do and leave it at that, OK?)
mikemikeb
ParticipantI typically use png over tiff because tiff isn’t truly standardized. I discoverd this when I tried out Bibble and found that GIMP didn’t like Bibble’s tiffs and Bibble didn’t like GIMP’s tiffs.
If we’re going from unprocessed RAW to final full-sized HDR JPEG in a single program (like CS2), then this shouldn’t be much of a problem. Besides, chakalakasp would say that it’s best to reach the 8-bit/JPEG level in CS2, anyway.
If you want an EXIF manipulation program, you can look into http://www.exiv2.org , though it sounds like stripping the EXIF won’t necessarily help you if PS is looking for it. And png’s and tiff’s don’t store it anyway, so if it’s an issue of PS demanding it, you may not be able to fool it.
Hopefully CS2 doesn’t care if all the images are EXIF-free. It shouldn’t. Also, according to Wikipedia, EXIF suppots TIFF files
I think the only downside to the whole system is that qpfstmo outputs 8bit png’s rather than 16 bit, though ultimately GIMP can only deal with 8 bit anyway. It sure would be nice if GIMP 2.4 had support for 16 or 32 bits/channel….
If I remember correctly, most DSLR’s (including modern Canons) have 12-bit RAW. Saving to 8-bit PNG will reduce overall dynamic range, right? If so, then saving to PNG doesn’t look too good for people with GIMP… Of course, if you’re using CS2, I guess that doesn’t apply, and I suppose that GIMP’s image scaling and JPEG editor/saving tools are underappreciated, and a full-size JPEG saved from CS2 will work fine in GIMP.
mikemikeb
ParticipantThe reason that photoshop gets upset is that when you change exposure and save the images again, the EXIF information no longer has an exposure value for photoshop to work with. … You could probably use an EXIF editor to add the EV into the image.. you might try that.
What about this: If saving to .png strips a RAW file of the EXIF data, how about a Save As of the unedited RAW file to PNG and working on the HDR from there? Or does the .png conversion keep the EXIF data? Is that what you already do, Elsinore?
mikemikeb
ParticipantProps to all of you who were actually able to produce usable HDR images this week. This contest was very educational for me, in that I learned how dullard-ic I am when it comes to the technical stuff.
My entry is the result of great frustration and annoyance and, while technically (in terms of process) is HDR, has absolutely none of the qualities associated with the technique.
To be honest, I had the same sort of problems as you, as my entry was my first try with HDR and it sure didn’t come out the way I wanted. The streetcorner wasn’t vivid enough, nor was the sky blue enough, and so on and so on. Plus, you really need to pick a good spot for an HDR photo, with plenty of highlights and shadows, and the living room isn’t really it. Trust me, you do have potential to get a good technical one. In fact, you already have in the Favorite Places contest, where you put the polarized sunglasses in front of the lens, and subsequently finished second, and you’re way more talented than me at photography in general. chakalakasp has the knack for picking the right place and shooting it in a proper way (including HDR), and I believe you can, too.
And speaking of you, chaka, I’ll second your congrats to SaintDiluted for that baseball pic. Not to diss your own photos, chaka, but that one is truly the best entered photo this week. Hey, at least you have the NYSE and NYC moon photos available if there’s ever a Classic HDR theme. If you’re ever perplexed with photo choices, you’re always invited to private message me for an honest opinion.
mikemikeb
ParticipantI spent a lot of time fighting with Photoshop CS2 and raw images, trying to split one raw shot into 3. Unlike with my bracketed shots, which worked fine, no matter how I split out the images, I got “not enough dynamic range to construct a useful HDR image” from photoshop. I played with moving EV’s around, played with curves, brightness, meditated on the beauty of histogram curves, but nothing I did seemed to work.
I don’t know myself, but if you don’t get a reply from her, I suggest private messaging SaintDiluted and/or chakalakasp with that question. Better yet, how about asking one of them pubicly how to do that, and have ’em post a response in this thread, or a new one?
Maybe I just need to go download the HDR stuff for the gimp.
Don’t do that! That stuff’s almost worthless if you want a good HDR result.
October 19, 2006 at 3:25 pm in reply to: well im trying to take some decent b&w.. any pointers? #6921mikemikeb
ParticipantYou’re welcome, ohiopyro.
I just got this additional thought in my head: With fireworks, take the pics in RAW and make a single-shot HDR out of them. Since I’m not a very talented post-processor, I’m not sure how to do this correctly, but I do know it’s possible. I suggest private messaging SaintDiluted and/or chakalakasp and asking for advice on how to do it.
Good luck!
October 19, 2006 at 3:19 am in reply to: well im trying to take some decent b&w.. any pointers? #6919mikemikeb
ParticipantI suggest taking all photos in color and convert to grayscale as desired in post-processing (and keep the color file handy aftrward), because you may otherwise miss out on a great color opportunity. Sure, it’ll take up more space on your memory card, but not much more, and once the photo is converted to grayscale/black and white, it’s practically impossible to re-colorize it correctly.
Besides, you’d be surprised what color can sometimes do! Would you want a black-and-white version of this?
As for your photos, some of them were good, and some weren’t. Either those fireworks weren’t too good, or you need to slow down your shutter speed to get more fireworks in in some cases. Zooming out can often help with fitting in fireworks, and remember to shoot at f/5.6 on the Av setting if you’re using the kit lens.
I’ll tell you though, fireworks are probably the most difficult things to photograph, because their behavior is wildly unpredictable. I probably couldn’t have done better than you.
mikemikeb
ParticipantI found that it worked much better if the darker exposure was on top of the lighter one.
I concur.
mikemikeb
ParticipantOK, I’ve tried the GIMP tool, and with my example, I haven’t been too impressed. It’s not a very intelligent tool, meaning, it applies the merging effect equally across the whole image, and not variably, which kind of sucks. It can’t detect the locations of the blown-out highlights, and apply the top layer in those areas alone. It also would be nice if the tool was intelligent enough that a variable amount of the top layer could be applied, depending on how much highlight clipping there actually is. That means, the top right of the photo would have a lighter blue hue.
What I did was expose two shots, both exposed to different metered levels, depending on where I aimed the camera (intersection vs. blue sky), and put ’em through the tool’s paces (and 1% blur, and not 0% blur, as an image apparently won’t be created at that setting). To demonstrate:
This is the merged image @ 100% opacity:

This is the merged image @ 35% opacity:

Only here do we have a relatively undisturbed foreground, but the sky looks rather drab. Can’t I have a way where the sky is left blue per No. 2, the intersection looks like No. 1, and the top right looks like something closer to No. 2 but not exactly it?
(Sorry, dial-up users)
mikemikeb
Participanti wonder though in the case of trifecta – hell should we have some sort of prize for that?
It’s not really a question of if he’ll do it, but I’ll see if I can make some sort of run for second place this weekend — the weather forecast looks great with the one shot (if it can be called such) I want!
mikemikeb
ParticipantTell them to also double check their computer calendar and clock settings. One thing Zeke and I found on some phpbb forums we run is that if the clock or calendar on your computer is off, it messes with the cookies, so it prevents login. I’m not talking a minute or two on the clock, more like several hours. Or if the calendar has accidently gotten bumped up to next month or next year, they won’t be able to login. It doesn’t seem like something that would happen often, but 90% of our login problems were resolved when the user checked their clock or calendar and fixed it if it was off.
On Win XP (and 2000?), this can helpfully be fixed automatically. Simply click the on the clock at the bottom of the screen twice (or right-click on the area and select “Adjust Date/Time”), then open the “Internet Time” tab on the resulting dialog. Then click “Update Now”. With a proper Internet connection, the entire time profile should update in about 30 seconds. You’ll know when it’s done when a message displays below the “Update Now” button that says, “The time has been successfully synchronized…” followed by some other mumbo-jumbo.
P.S. It helps to check-mark “Automatically syncronize with an Internet time server” (either server choice is fine) to keep proper computer time over the long haul. It also helps to check the time zone setting on the “Time Zone” tab on that same dialog.
mikemikeb
Participanti have heard from two people recently who had trouble becoming members. that is creating a user account. unfortuantely they were not too specific about what the problem was. fark user “Kopycat” said this in the PSAEF last night.
Also, my attempts to register there have been unsuccessful.
if the guy in question is from NY state around buffalo it’s one of the folks i was talking about. he mentioned you by name as trying to help him.
the guy that contacted me w/ trouble was in the CA area. i didn’t see how to get to the admin area for members, so i passed the buck to veruca & she said everything looked to be a go with his account and didn’t know why he couldn’t log in any more.
it’s all very odd.
Do they have cookies from “farktography.net” and “forum.farktography.net” enabled in their browser cookie whitelist? If they use IE, their security settings may be locked in too tight (therefore blocking the needed cookies) and they should use Firefox (which is a better general browser anyway) to allow cookies from those addresses. If anybody here wants to know how this is done, I can always follow-up post.
-
AuthorPosts


