Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
mikemikeb
ParticipantThanks to Elsinore and millera9 for their comments regarding the microwave pic. For anyone else that liked it, I’m pleased that you did.
As for millera9, it looks like you’ll edge out the victory this week. Congratulations!
mikemikeb
ParticipantCurious, I was curious about your 2007-02-21 08:03:06 PM, as I thought I saw it before. Sure enough, the FSM shows that it was entered in the On All Fours classic contest. Cute cats, though.
veruca, re your 2007-02-21 09:38:40 PM: You upgraded to Vista already? +1 vote (unrelated to the Vista upgrade) and -1 geek point for you!*
Oh, and millera9‘s car photo was the only photo where I dropped my jaw and exclaimed the equivalency of “Whoa…”, so I guess it was the best this week, at least to me. Zeke‘s winner wasn’t too bad, though, as I voted for it as well. Congrats, Southern Comfort Guy!
* I myself am not a geek
mikemikeb
ParticipantNice photos this week. Glad to see that I don’t need to participate for the good photos to stop. Oh, wait, most of my “good” photos still suck. Never mind.
Congrats, Otto’s_Jacket!
mikemikeb
ParticipantI had one of those sort of concerns about the Head-On parody in the “3.0” thread. I decided to let it in, hoping people solely saw it as me trying to channel staplermofo, and not misconstrue it as me trying to criticise him for having another kid, for whatever reason they made in their mind. It worked, but I wonder if something similar would work later, elsewhere.
mikemikeb
Participant“Congratulations, Schnee” — apply directly to the computer. “Congratulations, Schnee” — apply directly to the computer. “Congratulations, Schnee” — apply directly to the computer.
mikemikeb
ParticipantQuick question — Can I black-and-white-ify color photos, or must the items be originally gray in color?
mikemikeb
ParticipantI (currently) got nuthin’.
😯
Now, now, don’t pull any of that on us. There have to be three good entries somewhere in your archive. All my three entries this week are from archive-raiding. Your mundane virtuosity in photography astounds me — I’m not sure how I could get as many votes trying to emulate you (I tried once and failed miserably, remember?).
As for me, it’s now simply a matter of double-guessing, uploading my final entries, and waiting for the mainpage hit.
mikemikeb
ParticipantAfter doing a little research, should I go ahead and spend the extra $100-$150 and get the Canon EF 70-300mm f/4-5.6 IS USM Lens?
Ummm: No.
The problems start with the optical quality of the lens. Compared to the 28-135 IS, it leaves plenty to be desired. From your statements of what you thought of the 18-55, be ready to say “meh” with the 75-300 as well.
A 200mm lens = a 320mm field of view on your Rebel. This should be enough zoom, even for you, and if so, and only if 200mm eqivalency isn’t telephoto enough, try the 70-200 f/4 L that schnee has. The L has professional optics, and, more importantly, a full extra stop of light available at full telephoto, which really helps if you want to stop action, even outdoors. It’s available for about $600 on Amazon.com. There’s a more expensive version of that lens which adds IS, which might or might not be worth the extra $450+…
If 320mm (equivalent) even on a Rebel isn’t enough, the only decent Canon lens that goes from 70-300mm is the 70-300 DO IS. However, its contrast and bokeh aren’t the world’s greatest, and it’s over $1,000, even on Amazon.
I still say that if 200mm equivalency (on a Rebel) is enough, get the 28-135 IS. It’ll have faster AF than the 70-300 IS. It has a distance window, unlike the 70-300. Unlike the 70-300, the 28-135’s (and 70-200 L’s) front barrel doesn’t rotate when zooming, which is good for polarizing filter users, especially ones in fast action photography. It’ll be cheaper than the 70-200mm L.
The 28-135 IS and 70-200 f/4 L have a good balance of optics and price. The 70-300? Ummmmm…. no.
mikemikeb
Participantmikemikeb
Participant“VD (no, not THAT VD)”?
mikemikeb
ParticipantIf what would equate to 200-215mm on a film body is telephoto enough for you, I suggest the Canon EF 28-135mm IS lens. From your comments on the 18-55, I get the impression that this is the least expensive telephoto zoom lens that you’d be satisfied with. Thanks to the XTi’s 1.6x crop, the 28-135 has the sort of telephoto range on an XTi of a 200mm lens. In addition, the lens has something called IS, or Image Stabilization, which counteracts camera shake, which can help in many situations. It’s not going to stop action any faster than if the lens didn’t have IS, but the IS can stop action in a more tripod-like manner.
The amount of $$$ that Wolf Camera is selling the 28-135 for is a ripoff. In fact, even with the $100 gift card factored in, the price of the lens on Amazon.com is less than what you would pay at Wolf. Amazon has been known to be extremely reputable.
From my time at the Wolf website, I can’t see anything to recommend them when it comes to most things: They don’t sell the lens hood for the 28-135, or any other lenses that I searched for, for that matter, and there’s more from there that I won’t bore you on. I can’t see how that $100 could be spent on good accessories there, so I’d say that you should regift the card to someone who’s thinking of buying a new camera.
________________When it comes to SLR lenses, there are other things to think about. Ask any good photographer and they’ll tell you that a lens hood will add to color and contrast versus not having one. In addition, they’ll tell you that the hood also reduces lens flare. The results in the pictures are noticeable. The hood for the Canon 28-135, the EW-78B II, is about $30 on Amazon.
With the 50mm prime, you may choose not to get a hood. If you do, the Canon-recommended ES-62 does a fine job and costs less than $30. But I’ll let you in on a little secret: The ET-65 III fits just as well as the ES-62, adds additional flare protection without drawbacks in the picture results, and costs less than the ES-62 (under $20 on Amazon).
Then there’s the UV filter to think about. A good one may eke out further improvements in flare reduction and contrast. More importantly, as my high school photo teacher said, “Break a UV filter, buy a new filter. Break the glass on a lens, buy a new lens”. There are so many types of blunt objects, like the corners of a table at a diner, or a door handle, that can bypass a hood on a lens with a wide thread diameter, like the 28-135, and — whoops. In addition, a UV filter prevents scratching of the front of the lens glass, which can happen occasionally. Such scratching is also unrepairable.
There is a danger to UV filters, however. Using an inferior (cheap) version will degrade color and contrast. The least expensive UV filter that you can buy that delivers good quality is Hoya multicoated (a.k.a. Hoya HMC). One with a 72mm thread diameter (for the 28-135mm) will be around $32 (on Amazon)-50, and is worth every penny. Since the 50mm prime is so inexpensive, with such a thin thread diameter, I’d say that a filter for that lens is rather pointless, especially with the ET-65 III hood on it.
Finally, invest in a good scratch-free cleansing cloth to clean oil, dust, etc., off the UV filter or glass (in the case of the 50mm prime). I have one and I can say from experience that it’s worth every penny of the less than $10 it cost me.
________________Some of these accessories might push the final price to over $450. Bite the bullet, especially when it comes to any 28-135-related accessories, as you’re not going to find any high-enough-quality telephoto zoom lenses at lower prices, and those accessories might save you another $400+ in the future.
If 200mm isn’t telephoto enough for you, feel free to reply in this thread saying so.
mikemikeb
Participantmikemikeb
ParticipantSomebody in the Farktography higher-ups willing to Farkback?
mikemikeb
Participantdgough, when will you be leaving for work? If it’s before the greenlight, I could host (if you haven’t already) & post ’em. Go ahead and PM me the pics (or their links) if you want.
mikemikeb
ParticipantI have one of those 50mm lenses. Overall it’s not bad: It’s really sharp corner-to-corner once you stop it down to f/2.8, it’s light, and it’s cheap to replace. The bad news: Manual focus is really pokey, auto focus isn’t very accurate on my Rebel XT, even in good light, out-of-focus objects can appear pentagon-shaped, and color is poorly calibrated; specifically, it weakens blue and green and overdoes red. There’s a more expensive ($350) f/1.4 version that’s said to fix all these issues and provide faster performance (though again, from what I’ve seen, it needs to be stopped down to f/2.8 to provide sharp corner-to-corner results). In addition, any 50mm lens has a 50mm field of view only for film cameras (and maybe that $3000 5D). On your Rebel, with its 1.6x crop, it’ll be approximate to about 85mm on a film camera. That last fact makes it a good portrait lens for a Rebel, but not a general-purpose one.
Among other primes, the 24mm f/2.8 ($320) and 28mm ($200 for the f/2.8 version, about $450 for the f/1.8 ) are recommended. It’s generally regarded that the 24mm is sharper, and the 28mm is the closest thing to a 50mm equivalent lens on a Rebel-series camera, but suffers from rather inferior optical quality. I’d suggest the 24mm, as you can crop out stuff in post-processing and have room to spare resolution-wise.
Among zooms, the 24-85mm won’t set you back too much (about $350) and deliver you decent quality, not L quality, mind you, but it’s OK. I also suggest the 28-135mm IS model ($450-ish), which has more telephoto range and adds image stabilization to the mix. However, with the Rebel’s 1.6x crop, that 28mm at the wide end turns into 45mm on the XT, which is unacceptably telephoto, at least to me. (Even the 24mm’s 38mm equivalence is pushing it, but there aren’t any cheap and good prime lenses that go further out.)
Now those prices are for Canon lenses. You could get zooms (and, to a lesser extent, primes) from outside manufacturers, but they may not work properly with all Canon cameras. That said, the Tamron 17-50mm f/2.8 model is the best of the third-party bunch and should work properly with the Rebel XT. Even though auto-focus is a bit loud, the lens makes up for it with sharp performance, accurate autofocus, and a 35mm equivalence of 27mm ❗ at full wide angle. Best off, it costs about the same as the Canon 28-135, maybe a little more. I would much rather have the Tamron over the Canon 28-135.
And if you really hit a financial windfall, first get financial help, and then you can look at the Canon 17-40mm f/4 L, 16-35 f/2.8 L, 24-70mm f/2.8 L, and the EF-S (digital-only) 17-55 f/2.8 IS lenses, which will blow inferior lenses out of the water with their improved color and corner-to-corner sharpness. Careful, though: L-Disease can get very expensive to treat. (Note: The EF-S 17-55 technically isn’t an L, but it has the optical quality of one…)
P.S. Don’t forget the appropriate lens hood and UV filter for whatever lens you buy. When it comes to UV filters, Hoya provides a good multicoated (kind of required, as inferior filters degrade picture quality) experience at a good price, but it’s somewhat easy to smear and often hard to get the smear off. Get a good non-scratch cleansing cloth to clean it when needed. I say this from experience.
-
AuthorPosts





